|
New Delhi: A divided Union
Cabinet formally announced its decision not to challenge
Delhi High Court order legalising homosexuality before
the Supreme Court.
The Cabinet, chaired by Prime Minister Manmohan Singh,
decided to play it safe after some senior members
expressed reservations about the political impact of
legalising gay sex and decided to leave a decision on
article 377 to the Supreme Court, which will hear the
case on October 1.
Addressing a press conference in New Delhi after the
Cabinet meeting Union Information and Broadcasting
Minister Ambika Soni said that the Cabinet considered
the report of the three-member Group of Ministers and
decided that Attorney General of India Goolam E
Vahanvati will “assist” the Supreme Court in the case.
“The government has taken a firm decision after
considering the panel report. The Cabinet decided that
the Attorney General should assist the Supreme Court in
every way desired by the court to come at an opinion in
judging the correctness of the Delhi High Court order,”
said Soni.
She said the Supreme Court would decide if the High
Court was “right or not” in decriminalising
homosexuality.
Even though some Cabinet members expressed reservations
supporting gay rights law but the Cabinet refused to
take a stand on the controversial issue.
The three-member committee comprising Union Home
Minister P Chidambaram, Health Minister Ghulam Nabi Azad
and the Law Minister M Veerappa Moily had decided not to
oppose the Delhi High court judgement. Vahanvati had
already told the Supreme Court that government would not
oppose Delhi High Court order and he will assist the
apex court on Section 377 of Indian Penal Code relating
to homosexuality.
The Attorney General will leave the decision to the
Supreme Court when it hears the petition against the
High Court order on October 1.
Gay rights activists and lawyers are relieved that the
government decided against opposing the High Court
order. They say they are hopeful that the safe stand
will help their case in Supreme Court.
The Law Minister had already submitted a report to Prime
Minister Manmohan Singh on decision arrived by the
three-member panel. But reservation among some ministers
like Union Minister of Overseas Indian Affairs Vayalar
Ravi remained.
Earlier, in an interview to CNN-IBN Moily had said that
the government was impressed by the recent Delhi High
Court order legalising homosexuality.
“One thing must go to the credit of the Delhi High Court
judgement. It is well documented, well researched. I
must tell the judges... the subject may be different,
but at the same time this is one judgement which has
really stood out in the judicial annals of this
country,” Moily said.
When asked if the judgement was well researched and well
argued, Moily replied, “Well documented, well argued.”
The Delhi High Court had passed an order about two
months back legalising sex between consenting gay
partners, earlier considered a criminal act under
Section 377 of the IPC.
However, the ruling has been opposed by many religious
bodies. A Christian organisation, a disciple of Yoga
Guru Ramdev and Delhi Commission for Protection of Child
Rights (DCPCR) have approached the Supreme Court which
sought the government’s response by October 1.
The Supreme Court had earlier refused to stay the High
Court order, saying it would await the response of the
government.
|