|
London, 24 April 2010
(Telegraph): The Government has apologised to the Pope
over official documents that mocked his forthcoming
visit to Britain by suggesting he should bless a gay
marriage and even launch Papal-branded condoms.
The astonishing proposals, leaked to The Sunday
Telegraph, were contained in secret papers drawn up
earlier this month by civil servants following a
'brainstorm’.
The ideas, included in a memo headed 'The ideal visit
would see ...’, ridiculed the Catholic Church’s
teachings including its opposition to abortion,
homosexual behaviour and contraception. Many appeared to
be deliberately provocative rather than a serious
attempt to plan an itinerary for the September visit.
The proposals, which were then circulated among key
officials in Downing Street and Whitehall, also include
the Pope opening an abortion ward; spending the night in
a council flat in Bradford; doing forward rolls with
children to promote healthy living; and even performing
a duet with the Queen.
In reference to the hugely sensitive issue of child
abuse engulfing the Catholic Church, the Government
document suggests that the Pope should take a “harder
line on child abuse – announce sacking of dodgy bishops”
and “launch helpline for abused children”.
The document was sent out by a junior Foreign Office
civil servant with a covering note admitting that some
of the plans were “far-fetched”.
Recipients of the memo were furious at its content and
an investigation was launched. One senior official was
found responsible and has been transferred to other
duties.
Yesterday the Foreign Office issued a public apology
after being approached by The Sunday Telegraph, while
Francis Campbell, the UK ambassador to the Vatican, met
senior officials of the Holy See to express the
Government’s regret.
David Miliband, the Foreign Secretary, was “appalled” to
hear of the proposals, according to a source close to
him, and blamed “a colossal failure of judgement” by
officials involved.
A Foreign Office spokesman said: “This is clearly a
foolish document that does not in any way reflect UK
Government or Foreign Office policy or views. Many of
the ideas in the document are clearly ill-judged, naive
and disrespectful.
“The text was not cleared or shown to Ministers or
senior officials before circulation. As soon as senior
officials became aware of the document, it was withdrawn
from circulation.
“The individual responsible has been transferred to
other duties. He has been told orally and in writing
that this was a serious error of judgement and has
accepted this view.
“The Foreign Office very much regrets this incident and
is deeply sorry for the offence which it has caused.
He said: “This is appalling. You don’t invite someone to
your country and then disrespect them in this way.
“It’s outlandish and outrageous to assume that any of
the ideas are in any way suitable for the Pope.”
The Papal Visit Team reports to Dame Helen Ghosh, the
permanent secretary at the Department for Environment,
Food and Rural Affairs, and ultimately to Jim Murphy,
the Scotland Secretary, who is responsible for the trip.
The "ideal visit" list was circulated within Whitehall
by a junior Foreign Office official, an Oxbridge
graduate in his 20s.
In an emailed memo dated March 5, headed "Policy
planning ahead of the Pope’s visit", he invited senior
colleagues to attend an "inter-faith meeting" the
following week to discuss themes for the visit.
Attached to the memo were three "background documents",
including the "ideal visit" list, which he said would
form the basis of discussions. He added in the memo:
"Please protect; these should not be shared externally.
The ‘ideal visit’ paper in particular was the product of
a brainstorm which took into account even the most
far-fetched of ideas."
Recipients included Nicola Ware, a senior Foreign Office
official, as well as officials at 10 Downing Street, the
Department for International Development, and the
Northern Ireland Office.
The exercise appears to have been intended to ensure a
high impact for the papal visit and to identify areas
such as development and climate change on which the
Government and the Vatican could co-operate, but the
list of ideas has caused offence.
Bishop McMahon said Catholics would be concerned that
the document reflects the existence within Whitehall of
officials prejudiced against people of faith, and
predicted that it would cause embarrassment for the
Government. The Prime Minister said in last week’s party
leaders’ debate that he was looking forward to the papal
visit, but ministers have clashed repeatedly with the
Catholic Church over legislation.
There is understood to be increasing unease at the
Vatican over the level of hostility that the Pope is
likely to face in Britain, with protests and even
threats of arrest from secularists. The disclosure of
the secret proposals is bound to deepen concerns and
cause dismay among the country’s four million Catholics.
Further suggestions on the "ideal visit" list are that
the Pope should reverse the Church’s "policy on women
bishops/ordain woman" and that the Vatican should
"sponsor a network of Aids clinics".
Another of the three background documents, titled "Papal
Visit Stakeholders", lists figures and groups that the
officials consider significant to the tour, and ranks
them in order of how "influential" and "positive" each
one is perceived to be.
The Queen, David Cameron, and Tony Blair are all ranked
as highly influential and positive. It rates Susan
Boyle, the singer, as more influential than Vincent
Nichols, the Archbishop of Westminster.
Wayne Rooney, the footballer, who was married in a
Catholic Church, is considered to be a negative
influence, as are Madonna, the singer, and Richard
Dawkins, the prominent atheist professor. "Pro-choice
groups", homosexual pressure groups and the National
Secular Society are all viewed as negative.
|