|
Many male MPs in most
political parties, it is alleged, do not like to give up
their dominance in parliament and are opposed to the
passing of the women reservation Bill. While outwardly
pretending to support the Bill they conspire to defeat
it somehow. Those who are not even willing to abide by
the self-evident truth that all men are created equal
may find it even difficult to believe that all men and
women are created equal!
The initial euphoria over the success of the ruling
Congress in the Rajya Sabha with the help of the
Leftists and the BJP in passing the Woman’s Bill for
reservation of 33 per cent seats in Parliament is waning
due to the realization that the ruling alliance could
even lose power if allies opposed to such reservation
withdraw support to the alliance.
Though hailed as a historic measure leading to far
reaching social changes, it is now doubted whether Sonia
Gandhi will be able to go ahead with her determination
to see the Bill through in the Lok Sabha as well. The
arithmetic of numbers, according to observers, are not
in favour of the Congress.
In an effort to cool tempers, parleys were held among
the Congress leadership and the opponents, after the
Rajya Sabha and Lok Sabha witnessed unruly scenes
According to present indications, the Congress does not
want to derail the alliance at this juncture and might
try for a truce with alliance partners opposed to the
Bill. It may come up in the Lok Sabha only in May. There
is also a possibility, according to political observers,
that the percentage of reservation might be watered
down.
Opponents:
The Samajwadi Party, the Rashtriya Janata Dal and the
Janata Dal (United) led by Mulayam Singh Yadav, Lalu
Prasad Yadav and Sharad Yadav respectively are the main
opponents of the Bill. They aver that the Bill in its
present form does not provide for separate quotas for
women belonging to the SC, ST,OBC, Muslims and other
minorities.
While these leaders maintain that such reservation might
heavily favour women from the upper castes, it is quite
possible that they feel threatened by a resurgence of
women power. Even within the Congress and the BJP, there
are those who are not in favour of the male bastion of
parliament being thrown open to more women.
The hooliganism and histrionics that marked the
introduction of the 108th Amendment Bill in the Rajya
Sabha on March 9 is a true reflection of forces which
are against change and progress. Not long ago, one of
them—Mulayam Singh-- spoke against introduction of
computers and English education.
There are semi-literate sections including casteists in
the country, which keep battling for status quo,
whenever democratic measures are taken to create a more
egalitarian society. They oppose reforms intended to
bring about more justice and righteousness by holding
forth specious arguments.
Next to casteism, suppression of women is the other
social evil that obstructs progress of this nation with
half of its one billion inhabitants in fetters one way
or the other. Though women are the real architects of
society and the most effective tool of development as
former UN secretary general Kofi Annan described them,
they have long been denied their due in this nation.
Manu the ancient lawgiver considered women as the weaker
sex and unworthy of freedom. Virginia Wolf, English
author and feminist has held that the ‘history of men's
opposition to women's emancipation is more interesting
perhaps than the story of that emancipation itself.’
Even though they make up half the population, women have
endured discrimination in most societies for thousands
of years. In the past, women were treated as property of
their husbands or fathers - they couldn't own land, they
couldn't vote or go to school, and were subject to
beatings and abuse and could do nothing about it.
Some progress has been made in the past century in
improving their position, but many in backward regions
like Bihar and UP still live without the rights to which
they are entitled.
Asfemale foeticide so amply demonstrates the conspiracy
against the girl child begins in the womb. She is to
bear the drudgery of the households unlike the male
child, bargained over dowry at the time of marriage and
then subjected to the vagaries of the man she marries.
If widowed she is just a bad omen and while advanced in
age, often a burden for others in the home. The female
of the species thus faces a journey marked by pain and
suffering from birth to death.
Difficulties:
Women have a right to live in dignity, in freedom from
want and fear. It is said that when we educate a man we
educate an individual; but when we educate a woman, we
educate a whole family and even the coming generations.
Women’s suffrage pioneer of the US in the nineteenth
century, Susan B. Anthony held that ‘there will never be
complete equality until women themselves help to make
laws and elect law makers.’
It is important that all public spirited citizens, both
men and women kept up the fight for giving equality to
women. It is time that the old mind-set that ‘woman is
to man as the slave to the master’ is given up.
A debate has raged over the Bill and writers recalled
difficulties that plague Indian women like economic
dependence on men, lack of education and the feudal
structure of society. Missionaries had attempted to
remedy matters by promoting education of women and
campaigning against evil practices like ‘Sati’ long ago.
William Carey had to face opposition even from the Hindu
leaders of his time while he campaigned for abolition of
‘Sati’ (the practice of women committing suicide by
jumping into the funeral pyre of their husbands).
The role of women missionaries like Ida Scudder, Edith
Brown and Priscilla Winter in launching hospitals in
Vellore, Ludhiana and Delhi for the health care of women
in the 1800s when such facilities were almost
non-existent is worth recalling.
Another prominent champion of the rights of Indian woman
was Pandita Ramabai, also a poet and scholar. She has
been acclaimed as a "mother of modern India." In her own
time she struggled hard, as a Christian convert, to
define her own identity. She remains a bold role model
for all those who would work for the emancipation of
women, with her efforts to rehabilitate widows and
orphans.
While hoping that sooner or later the Lok Sabha will
endorse reservation of seats for women, this is only the
opening of the doors of opportunity for woman in a
significant way. Much will depend on what impact the
women will be able to make on democracy and justice in
society.
In April 1993, the 73rd Constitutional Amendment Act
came into force in states reserving 33 per cent of seats
in Panchayati Raj institutions for women. This is said
to have led to a silent revolution in the countryside
resulting in the empowerment of women. There are several
reasons why an increased role for women would lead to
healthy politics and better governance. They are more in
touch with realities and the day-to-day problems and
would be more sensitive to issues of development. They
have a greater stake in health care, education and other
essential provisions like drinking water.
Women’s education in Kerala had contributed much to the
improvement of the status of women and has ensured for
her a life with dignity. But their counterparts in the
northern states still suffer from the slavery and
oppression practiced for long in the name of casteism.
Changing their mindset and instilling confidence in them
to work for their own emancipation would be challenging
tasks.
|